shattered glass moral lesson
In 1998, Glass, a suave, imminently personable star reporter for The New Republic ("The in-flight magazine of Air Force One!") A flimsy framing device in which Glass lectures a high school class is both distracting and unnecessary, since it merely restates the fact that Glass' predilection for fictional storytelling ultimately overwhelmed his grasp on reality, and the film's predictability intermittently sabotages the film's tension. Miller, C. (2011, November 17). Stephen Glass should’ve worked in fiction. Shattered Glass Study Guide For Teachers 10th - Higher Ed Students view a movie about ethical journalism and Stephen Glass' rise at The New Republic. Posted at 01:41 PM in Reviews - Blog Only | Permalink, The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo (2011): B+, The Blossoming of Maximo Oliveros (2005): B+, Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial-No Derivative Works 3.0 License. This resource packet presents a variety of ideas, lesson plans and activities to teach about the Holocaust. Upon being placed in a similar circumstance I would never recommend fabricating any sort of story for personal gain. The Shattered Glass. On Wednesday, September 23, 2015 students gathered in the First Amendment Forum to watch Shattered Glass. One ethical message that I can pull from this film derives from truth. from Stephen Glass. All editors rely on their reporters and reporters rely on their sources. Would be great for a Socratic Seminar. Stephen Glass was accused of fabricating his articles after an online journalist looked into Stephen Glass’ sources. Shattered Glass is such a tremendous film to teach about ethics and journalism but keeping the discussion focused can be challenging. In an article by Cheryl Miller, she wrote of how the supreme court, for the first time in eleven years, had taken review of Stephen glass’ entrance for the bar exam due to a moral character case. « Bad Santa (2003): A- | Seeing it as a young journalist in training, the film had a profound effect on me. Shattered Glass is a 2003 biographical drama film about journalist Stephen Glass and his scandal at The New Republic.Written and directed by Billy Ray, the film is based on a 1998 Vanity Fair article of the same name by H. G. Bissinger and chronicles Glass' fall from grace when his stories were discovered to be fabricated. As a student who's spent the last three months learning about journalistic ethics at Columbia University's Graduate School of Journalism, I had a special interest in catching Shattered Glass, the story of disgraced writer Stephen Glass. Features:-Fully B&W printable-Higher order thinking questions-Accountability for movie viewing That, i… Justices to Decide if Lying Journalist Fit to Practice Law. Stephen Glass broke these rules years ago and he is now being used as a lesson in college courses on what not to do. This movie brought up a lot of ethical issues based on Glass's behavior as a journalist. Plot and Issues Supported-Sources & Thoughts Legal and Ethical Questions Not to exceed 30 minutes or go under 20. The people at the outlets that Glass worked at put their faith in him. Students test a reporter’s ability to judge character, sharpen their fact-checking skills, explore the tensions built into the editorial process, and investigate other real-life cases that have put the ethics of journalism into … Letter to D.A.R.E. A journalist has the moral responsibility of reporting the truth and that was not the case throughout the movie. These tactics are implemented by great writers. Two things a journalist is never supposed to do. The movie "Shattered Glass" is a perfect portrayal of a man who lost his integrity due to his dishonest character. Women Shattered the Glass Ceiling, but Where Are the Support Beams? His downfall was lead by Chuck Lane, the lead editor… He even references the Stanford Prison Experiment as evidence but the consequences of being caught would be far too great. Glass had Fabricated more than half of his stories at The New Republic. “Shattered Glass” shows the importance of practicing ethical journalism. Apparently, if you google, the same can happen with with glass sinks or glass furniture and even shelves inside the fridge. His Lane is a powerhouse illustration of a journalist following his best instincts, and a welcome counterbalance to the shameful Stephen Glasses and David Blairs of the world who have helped further sully the profession's already-shaky reputation. (2014). Glass had Fabricated more than half of his stories at. Two programs featuring female coders in this lesson are working to change that statistic and break the glass ceiling. Shattered Glass (2003) ... Sarsgaard was subtle but incredibly engrossing as an editor in the middle of an increasingly complex and moral dilemma. Retrieved from, https://www.law.com/therecorder/almID/1202532869843&slreturn=1/?slreturn=20200113224704, Wendel, W. B. Shattered Glass and the story of Stephen Glass, although fascinating and disturbing brings up a valid point. Note: Technically this plot description will spoil the film but, seeing as how it closely follows the well-known true story, it shouldn’t be much of a spoiler at all. The movie portrays a very young journalist, Stephen Glass, who seemed to be doing everything correctly and very well organized. Yet it also inspires and uplifts us by reminding us that men of integrity will almost always triumph over men of little or no integrity in the long run. Stephen Glass was a journalist at “New Republic”. He is seen as the wunderkind at his high school alma mater, and is well liked and respected among his New Republic colleagues. Twenty-five year old Stephen Glass is the youngest of fifteen writers/editors at The New Republic, a little distributed but highly regarded - especially among those that matter, such as the President - political commentary magazine based in Washington, DC. I know numerous students who got through their high school careers plagiarizing and just breezing though with pieces that were not 100% theirs. Not only did he lie and make up stories, but he went to extreme lengths to cover up those lies and doing this made a lot of his colleagues look very stupid. The moral: Don't clean your glass shelves, and if you do, wear safety goggles and protective gear. One ethical message that I can pull from this film derives from truth. One’s reputation is something that is forever carried and to ruin something of that manner can be extremely detrimental. Stephen Glass, Situational Forces, And The Fundamental Attribution Error. Glass (Star Wars' Hayden Christiansen, exuding repulsive arrogance) is portrayed as a chronic flatterer with rampant insecurities, and his childish retorts to his boss' pointed questions ("Are you mad at me?") The Newspaper was one of the most popular political newspapers at the time and was even said to be the only newspaper to be on the president’s Air Force One. The movie Shattered Glass showcases a man in his quest for fame at his job. 'Shattered Glass' is an ineffably sad film, one that makes us mourn the loss of a promising, talented individual who sowed the seeds of his own destruction (he is currently a lawyer). Justices to Decide if Lying Journalist Fit to Practice Law. reveal his profoundly arrogant belief that his superficial charm and likeability could conceal his morally bankrupt behavior. ... sharing, emotion, immanence, and process. Retrieved from, https://heinonline.org/HOL/Page?collection=journals&handle=hein.journals/joolaw4&id=106&men_tab=srchresults, Glass, S. (1999, January 25). and people affiliated with D.A.R.E”. was discovered to have fabricated 27 of the 41 stories he had written for the publication, and what's amazing is how thrilling -- if strikingly discomfiting -- screenwriter Billy Ray's directorial debut (based on a Vanity Fair article by Buzz Bissinger) is. A journalist has the moral responsibility of reporting the truth and that was not the case throughout the movie. Glass had a very timid nature but the privileges he abused followed him for years to come even as he attempted to shift careers. Miller, C. (2011, November 17). 'Shattered Glass' is an ineffably sad film, one that makes us mourn the loss of a promising, talented individual who sowed the seeds of his own destruction (he is currently a lawyer). Another Ethical message that can be obtained from this film is the deception of fabrication. One thing I have taken from this section is that when it comes to journalism, you must always take the best precaution to ensure that you are doing everything ethically. Retrieved from https://heinonline.org/HOL/Page?collection=journals&handle=hein.journals/joolaw4&id=106&men_tab=srchresults, Glass, S. (1999, January 25). The Newspaper was one of the most popular political newspapers at the time and was even said to be the only newspaper to be on the president’s Air Force One. Use this guide to help students with their discussion. Stephen Glass broke many ethical codes with his actions during his time at the New Republic. Stephen Glass committed a very serious offense in deceiving his readers and colleagues. Glass was hired almost immediately after graduation from the University of Pennsylvania by The New Republic, where he initially served and was quickly promoted to writing features. The film was “Shattered Glass.” ... arguing that he does not meet the “moral character” standards required of lawyers. The story of Stephen Glass was tragic: a young journalist with so much potential fabricating dozens of stories for one of the top newspaper companies in the United States. SHATTERED GLASS is a sobering, enlightening, well-acted story of journalistic deceit and journalistic integrity, but it contains … Stephen Glass was a young, hungry, and gifted writer at a top-notch news magazine, The New Republic. Journalism is a field based on truth. Main In a letter to D.A.R.E, a drug education program, Stephen glass apologizes for damaging their reputation due to a fabricated article, “I want to express my regret and apology for falsely disparaging D.A.R.E. There are consequences to breaking any of these rules that could affect you, your peers, and whatever you represent. (2014). If I were to write a story I would collect the facts and envision an interesting story based on those facts. ''Shattered Glass'' is good enough to be true. What starts as a prominent hacker piece is shown to be a web of lies. Stephen Glass lost all of his credibility after he started to make up stories while he was working for a newspaper called New Republic. A journalist has the moral responsibility of reporting the truth and that was not the case throughout the movie. He undermined the credibility of the very outlet that gave him a chance to write stories. “Shattered Glass”, a biopic about Stephen Glass, weaves the tale of a young journalist who’s story snowballs into an ethical controversy. All students will be supplied with any and all materials needed, a class notebook with basic instruction, tips, hints, and info on where to buy ArtResin, glass, canvas, and more. Shortly after Glass’ actions had been exposed the newspaper took a steady decline. Chuck is initially shown to be little more than a petty butt-kisser and is repeatedly accused of holding a vendetta against anyone, in particular Glass, who is still loyal to Kelly. Shortly after Glass’ actions had been exposed the newspaper took a steady decline. I saw “Shattered Glass” for the first time as part of a collegiate journalism convention. Stephen Glass, Situational Forces, And The Fundamental Attribution Error. Shakespeare’s Richard II and the Crisis of Hermeneutics Jean-Marc Chadelat ... should/could teach moral and political lessons relevant for the present time. Because the audience knows going in that Glass, who was eventually discovered as a fraud by reporters at Forbes Digital Online, is a conniving liar, Ray stages the film not as a mystery but as a case study in all-consuming denial and professional and psychological self-destruction. In a dissenting review from The Village Voice, J. Hoberman dismissed the film as "self-important yet insipid," and asks, "Shattered Glass begs a larger question: What sort of culture elevates Glass for his entertainment value, punishes him for being too entertaining, rewards his notoriety, and then resurrects him again as a moral object lesson?" Retrieved from, https://www.nationalfamilies.org/prevention/glass_letter.html, Blog 4 – Reflections on this course by Evan Patrick, Blog 4 Course Reflection – Victor Cervantes, Ethical Lessons learned from Foster-Foreman Lectures by Xiaohua Li. After 16 years, the New Republic’s fabulist Stephen Glass is back in the news. Read Forbes' original stories that exposed the then-25-year-old's lies. It is important to discuss these issues because of how fast news travels in today’s society. Another Ethical message that can be obtained from this film is the deception of fabrication. Apparently, there can be small defects in the glass which cause it to explode for no apparent reason. Shattered Glass. Early 1998. Shattered Glass was an ideal film to show because its theme of honesty is so unbelievably applicable and important to the students at the Cronkite School of Journalism and Mass Communication. Retrieved from https://www.nationalfamilies.org/prevention/glass_letter.html. Still, Peter Sarsgaard's performance as the magazine's editor Chuck Lane is one of the year's finest, a perfectly calibrated rendering of investigative suspicion, staunch courage and moral clarity in the face of dislike and distrust from his embittered colleagues. In this perspective, the sense of loss ... has nevertheless fallen into moral bankruptcy of a worse kind boding ill for the future3. ''Shattered Glass'' is rated PG-13 (Parents strongly cautioned). Letter to D.A.R.E. News stories need to promote understanding, not deception. Their reputation was tarnished. Shattered Glass allowed future journalists an insight to how dangerous plagiarism and fabrication are when writing stories. The story of Stephen Glass should be familiar to most in journalism but it bears repeating. Based on a book by W. Bradley Wendel, he suggests that anyone would do the same if they were placed in a similar situation. Throughout the movie, “Shattered Glass,” the story was able to depict a perfect situation in which a journalist completely disregards codes of ethics to obtain personal satisfaction and interest from the general public. Sarsgaard makes Lane a hero not by empowering him with noble righteousness, but by showing him to be merely an inquisitive journalist determined to pursue the truth despite the possibly disgraceful consequences. Integrity is the most fragile value in journalism. | Elephant (2003): C+ ». Glass samples will have to be labeled appropriately to match the information on the student handout for suspect’s 1-5 (add or remove information from the student handout as necessary). from Stephen Glass. On the contrary, Stephen was lying about some of the events he had written about and even made up details to support these lies. in the above-referenced articles by willfully fabricating several incidents … I did this in order to sensationalize the stories without regard to the harm and detriment my fabrications and falsehoods would cause to D.A.R.E. The story of Stephen Glass, denounced for journalistic fraud in 1998, sets the stage for debate on editorial practices and ethical standards in this study guide to the film Shattered Glass. It has some profanity and one sexually suggestive scene. Retrieved from https://www.law.com/therecorder/almID/1202532869843&slreturn=1/?slreturn=20200113224704, Wendel, W. B. Shattered Glass is about a former journalist named Stephen Glass. Yet it also inspires and uplifts us by reminding us that men of integrity will almost always triumph over men of little or no integrity in the long run. Their reputation was tarnished. Another Ethical message that can be obtained from this film is the deception of fabrication. SHATTERED GLASS tells the true story of a young reporter working at a famous liberal magazine who is caught inventing false stories. A flimsy framing device in which Glass lectures a high school class is both distracting and unnecessary, since it merely restates the fact that Glass' predilection for fictional storytelling ultimately overwhelmed his grasp on reality, and the film's predictability intermittently sabotages the film's tension. Pretty scary. Get Shattered Advanced Workshop is a comprehensive 2-day workshop focusing on the start to finish creation of your very own unique shattered glass art piece. The movie portrays a very young journalist, Stephen Glass, who seemed to be doing everything correctly and very well organized. Auto glass is designed to break into pieces that are less sharp than regular glass; however for safety have students handle glass with forceps. At 25, Stephen Glass was the most sought-after young reporter in the nation’s capital, producing knockout articles for magazines ranging from The New Republic to Rolling Stone. Years later, it is fair to say it is the source of my strong journalistic moral code. the story was able to depict a perfect situation in which a journalist completely disregards codes of ethics to obtain personal satisfaction and interest from the general public.